Should I Give My Dog a Homemade Diet?

Our canine companions are part of the family, so naturally, we want them to share in everything we do. Some owners have started lovingly creating meals at home for their pups. This has led to a rising trend in homemade diets, with aesthetically pleasing videos uploaded across social media.

So, are homemade diets better than premade foods? Our canines have been sharing table scraps with us for thousands of years, so the latest homemade diet trend is surely just a wholesome upgrade.

For some dogs with medical needs, homemade diets (with veterinary support) can be the right option. However, it is important to acknowledge that creating a balanced, complete homemade diet takes lots of money, time and extensive vet advice.

So, before you commit to making all your pup’s meals, it is worth taking the time to understand the ins and outs of homemade diets.

Are Homemade Diets Healthier?

At a glance, homemade diets can certainly appear healthier, after all, what could be unhealthy about a plate of meat, eggs and vegetables?

However, feeding a nutritionally unbalanced or incomplete diet can lead to problems and illnesses. These problems tend to be worse with growing puppies, but are also seen in adult pets.

Providing your dog with a diet insufficient in calcium or not achieving the correct calcium: phosphorus balance has been seen to cause metabolic bone disease and secondary hyperparathyroidism.

Dogs have also been reported to suffer from skeletal disease, vitamin D deficiency and taurine deficiency.

A comprehensive study of 200 homemade diets, with feeding plans written by both veterinarians and owners, showed that these recipes were not nutritionally complete.

Furthermore, most of these recipes had vague instructions (feeding amounts, preparation, etc), and few cited the need for added supplements.

Although more research is needed, and this is by no means a reflection of ALL homemade diets. It cannot be denied that balancing a dog’s diet can be extremely difficult.

Choosing a natural, complete raw or dry diet takes the hard work away and gives owners confidence that their dog is getting everything they need.

Are Homemade Diets Cheaper?

Many owners turn to homemade diets as a way of saving money and keeping their pets well-fed.

Although every homemade recipe is going to be slightly different, the reality is that homemade diets tend to be on the more expensive side. Especially when you throw those much-needed supplements into the mix (oil, joint prebiotic), the cost is likely to far exceed the price of a complete diet.

If cost is a factor, there will be a complete natural food to suit every budget; some high-quality diets can cost as little as 70p per day.

Are Homemade Diets Time Consuming?

There is no getting around this one; making your dog’s dinner is going to take up a lot of your time.

Those who are creating balanced, nutritional homemade diets are putting in many hours of planning, research and recipe development. Some owners will have the time and energy to do this; however, many owners will not

Modern life is busy. Feeding a complete raw diet is a convenient way to provide your dog with exceptional nutrition, while taking a fraction of the time.

Do I Need to Avoid Certain Ingredients in Homemade Diets?

There are many ingredients that will need to be avoided if you are making a homemade dog diet.

Here are some to stay far away from:

• Grapes/ Raisins
• Avocado
• Garlic/Onions/Chives/Shallots/Leeks
• Cooked Bones

Some ingredients won’t need to be avoided; however, they will need to be measured and controlled. This will mean careful research and veterinary advice are needed for creating safe homemade dinners for your dog.

If you want more information on what you CAN feed your canine companion, read our Guide to Safe Human Foods for Dogs.

Can a Homemade Diet Benefit Dogs with Allergies?

Yes, a homemade diet can be useful for dogs with allergies and sensitivities. This is because you can tailor your dog’s meal and avoid using ingredients they react badly to.

However, with clear composition lists and many foods containing novel proteins, it is easier than ever to find a complete pre-prepared diet to suit your dog.

After more information about dog intolerances? Read our Guide to Chicken Allergies.

When it comes to homemade diets, there is a lot to consider. There can be benefits, but of course, there are downsides too.

If you decide to create your meals, keep in contact with a veterinary professional. Regular vet check-ups are so important for spotting issues and ensuring your dog remains healthy and happy